Of The Weirdest – Book 1 – Chapter 11

Of The Weirdest – Book 1 – Chapter 11

Well, this certainly wasn’t ideal. At all.

Cecelia was seated alone outside, eating the sandwich she’d packed for lunch and lamenting in her head about the events of her day so far. Tessa and Violet were both out sick, her classes were boring, and she felt absolutely exhausted no matter what she tried. Munching angrily on one of the pickles between the slices of bread, she couldn’t help but bitterly mull over what a terrible day it was, and how the sun was too bright, and how mad she was that she hadn’t gotten to finish talking to Ryder about her strange dreams… or that she’d even tried to in the first place. What was she thinking?

Cecelia had never been prone to nightmares before moving to Oakwood, but the things she’d seen in her mind last night had been so vivid and terrifying that she genuinely felt a little sick thinking about them. She’d been standing in the place with the rusty stop sign again, but it had been darker, and she was alone. Her body had been frozen, with nothing she could do to look away or pry herself awake as she watched it. Two luminous white eyes like headlights. A mouth full of teeth too big for it, splitting apart the face like an anglerfish, set in a permanent grimace that Cecelia instinctually read as pain. A long neck, swaying like a snake in a charmer’s basket. Huge ears, a physique that looked deformed and starved, two tiny wings that looked like they’d been in an oil spill. It was pitch black, like the smoke directly from a smokestack or iodine poured all over the floor. Slimy. Sludgy. Sickening.

It wasn’t like the thing had actually done anything – most of what it had done was loom there and stare ominously down at her with its foglight eyes – but the act of seeing it alone was still enough to make Cecelia feel a deep, abiding sense of dread. She knew it had something to do with the stop sign and the goo on it, and she knew it meant harm. It meant a lot of harm, and that shook her to her very core. What it was and what it meant was unknown to her, but instinct answered her with all she needed: whatever that thing was, she needed to fear it with the primal revilement of a prey animal facing down a predator in its last moments.

And beyond that primal revilement, the terror was boosted by the bone-deep knowledge that something about it was real.

… At least the pickles tasted nice, though. Roast beef, dill pickles, and a bit of American cheese was a good combination, and Cecelia commended herself for choosing it. After such a long day (that was barely halfway through), the respite of food was an entirely welcome one. She watched from the shade as a group of kids raced around and played a game of basketball. Cecelia didn’t particularly enjoy sports, nor could she tell the teams apart, but she kind of liked counting the amount of times the ball went through a hoop. 15 so far.

Make that 16… 17… Jesus Christ, that guy’s quick.

The ball bounced off the backboard before 18 could be made, and landed among the crowd of kids, who immediately swarmed it like piranhas discovering a burger patty in their water. Cecelia leaned back, putting down her sandwich for a moment to pull her grey hoodie a little tighter over her head, then stretched her legs out in front of her to cross them at the ankles while she continued her meal. 

As much as she just wanted to watch the ball game, there were things to ponder.

The dream, the way Leroy had been even more quiet than usual, the fact that Ryder and Avery even existed, the handful of obviously nonhuman classmates she had, the way nobody seemed to bat an eye at the strangeness, the fact that nobody even talked about it… The list went on and on. In truth, she’d been partially hoping Violet and Tessa would be in today so she could try to get more information out of them, but the bottom of her gut told her they wouldn’t. Whatever was happening, it was her job to get used to it on her own.

“Stay in Oakwood long enough and you’ll learn to recognize newcomers on sight.”

She knew what Eric meant now. In a town where the extraordinary was just… ordinary, it was probably pretty hard not to notice someone who acted like their previous life had been made of white bread. 

… She just hoped she could adjust to the learning curve. And soon.

This place? Freakier than she’d thought.


By the time she was at home, Cecelia had already sulked her way through what felt like four out of five stages of grief. Sitting in her room glaring at her bedsheets like they’d personally insulted her religion, she kept looping over the same thing in her head again and again. How exactly it had taken her five whole days to arrive at the conclusion of “this place is actually kind of concerning” was beyond her, but boy was she miserable at the destination.

How did she even get to this point?

Time to rehash. Again.

So her family had come here to get away from… well, from the suburban hell of San Jose, and the wreckage one woman had left of them there. They’d wanted a fresh start, a place where the days weren’t passed with yelling and Cecelia wasn’t singled out for being different in her own home. They’d wanted a place where all three of them could heal and learn to love again.

And apparently that place was also haunted. Really haunted.

What am I even doing?! C’mon, I’m supposed to just function!

Another rough twitch of her head caused Cecelia to grunt and rub the nape of her neck. Normally, her tics were a part of her life she didn’t really notice, – they came to her as naturally and regularly as breathing – but distress always made them flare alongside her irritation. Since getting out of school that afternoon, she’d been unable to stop cracking her joints, and whatever words she could come up with felt like poison behind her teeth, so she’d just decided not to say anything. When her father and brother had told her they were going out for groceries, she didn’t even say goodbye. She just waved.

A fresh start, a new town with a new school and new friends, streets full of new people and adventures… all spoiled, apparently. Every dream crushed, every sense of peace shattered, every daydream disrupted. Sure, she’d been curious at first, but between the increasingly strange people she encountered and the odd sayings and the nightmares, curiosity curdled quickly into anger.

How come she hadn’t noticed earlier? How come she hadn’t gotten mad sooner?

That was what bothered her the most. The latency of the realization. Four days of denial, treating everything like it was normal despite the lingering signs that it simply wasn’t. Four days of pushing aside strange sights and even stranger dreams to continue living like nothing was out of place. Four days of seeing everything as fine, until one stupid, meaningless nightmare took it all away.

And the worst part?

Cecelia was finally opening her eyes after just five days, but her family? Her family was still behaving like everything was just… ordinary. Just the same as it had always been.

Maybe it was just her disability struggling to accept the change in routine. Maybe it was just her residual anger poking through while her emotional regulation caught up with the adjustment in her world. Maybe it was nothing at all, and she was just going crazy for no reason.

… But she wasn’t. Cecelia wasn’t crazy. She knew she wasn’t crazy. Leroy had seen Ryder too! That had to count as something, didn’t it? Ryder was real, Avery was real, the agents in the woods the other day were probably real… and that meant the dream was also real. 

That was the part that kept throwing her for a loop. She’d go from denial to frustration, then into bargaining and rationalization, and then into a sense of woe that her life had ended up this way. Denial, anger, bargaining, depression, but never acceptance.

Acceptance meant realizing that there was something true about that dream. Acceptance meant that the terror was real, and that the suspiciously familiar figures around the stop sign were connected to more than just her unconscious mind. Acceptance meant admitting that there was something lurking in this town. Acceptance meant losing her idealized version of a brand-new start.

What the hell is out there?

Visions of red hair, flannel fabric, dusty blue clothes. Twin snouts. Gray fur.

More importantly: is it coming for us?

Air. She needed air.


In a perfect world, putting on your shoes without tying them and then sprinting like a madwoman towards the nearest pond to clear your head was something that should’ve won Cecelia a gold medal. Unfortunately, this was not a perfect world. Careening down the hiking trail like a runaway train car, the brunette didn’t find herself greeted with a finish line or a “Congratulations, Ms. Hawthorne! You won the race!” followed by several handfuls of confetti. She did, however, find something that her frazzled mind called just as good.

“So anyways, I told Trevor his guitar playing was pretty good, and then he said something like ‘I’m chuffed to bits’ and I just kind of stood there, I guess? I dunno, I don’t even know what that means, so-”

“It means he was extremely pleased. You made him happy, Avery.”

“Oh.”

Cecelia had to throw herself off course at the last second to stop herself from bodyslamming the unsuspecting Avery, who was leaning against one of the fences surrounding the pond, talking to Ryder. “Oof!”

Two pairs of eyes on her, followed by a cautious, steady hand with calloused fingertips. “Hey, hey, whoa there. You okay, kiddo?”

“I’m fine,” Cecelia replied hurriedly, standing up a little straighter and checking herself for any scrapes or splinters. None, though she’d probably bruise later. “Sorry. I was just trying not to run into you.”

Avery, who was leaning over her like a cautious giant, huffed a half-laugh, half-sigh of relief. “Oh, okay. Good. That’s good,” they breathed, sounding even more winded than she was. “You scared me for a moment there! Don’t just come careening around corners like that, you’re gonna break something someday.”

Ryder poked their head and upper body a little further over the railing, craning their neck to get a look at the panting middle schooler. “Hey,” they greeted gently, looking at Cecelia like they weren’t sure if she was going to bite them or not. “Is everything okay?”

Cecelia, despite her appreciation of Ryder’s support of her that morning, knew better than to answer truthfully. Things were definitely not okay, but telling a stranger you saw them in a recurring dream about a rusty stop sign was weird, even for her. She’d already made up her mind that it was a bad idea, even if she was definitely disappointed that her original plan had been so rudely interrupted.

Also, asking about it meant accepting that something was off, and accepting that something was off meant vulnerability.

“I’m okay,” she replied, tamping down her body’s attempt to twitch one of her fingers again. Suppressing her tics was a wall for her, a protective barrier between her delicate insides and the eyes of those she didn’t trust. Openly twitching and stimming was for time spent alone with her dad and brother only. “It’s just been a long day.”

Avery huffed again, though this time the sound leaned closer to a quiet chortle. “I can imagine. I’m so glad Ryder and I went to homeschool instead. Having classmates always sounded like hell.”

“You were homeschooled?”

“Our current occupation isn’t something that the school here could’ve provided us the materials for,” Ryder replied. “A lot of non-humans are educated differently.”

Avery nodded, crossing their arms along the railing so they could lean out and look at the gradually fading light glinting across the pond. “It depends a lot on your species, who your parents are, what you want to do with your life, where you’re from… that kind of thing.”

“Oh,” replied Cecelia, processing the information for a moment. It was more complex than she wanted to deal with today, but it sounded simple enough at its core. Selection based on practicality, just like humans did.

But if she couldn’t ask about the dream anymore, and she didn’t want any more information that would require deep cognitive thought…

“Who’s Trevor?”

“British,” Avery replied as though that was an answer.

“She said who, Avery,” Ryder pointed out softly in a tone that suggested this was not the first time they’d done this. Cecelia cocked her head like a little dog.

“Hey now,” Avery replied being completely serious, “Who’s to say being British can’t be part of who you are?”

It was obvious to the other two that Avery was attempting to cover up the fact that they’d only been half-listening to the conversation, but it was effectively shut down by the point they had made. With a soft sigh, Ryder conceded, but the glimmer in their eyes suggested a sense of affection that overrode any frustration.

Just like Leroy.

“Anyways,” the shorter of the two spirits continued, casting their gaze to Cecelia while Avery stared very intently at the fish in the pond below, “Trevor’s one of the local ghosts. He… well… I guess you could say he works for an important figure in this town. Really he’s just a normal guy, though.”

“He plays bass guitar,” Avery added, still focused on the fish. “We were talking about it earlier today when I bumped into him after my morning walk. I think I probably came across as a big doofus.”

The last sentence was laced with a self-deprecating huff, which Cecelia felt as a pang in her own heart. Was Avery a big doofus? From what she’d seen, almost certainly – but doofushood wasn’t necessarily a bad thing. If she could’ve picked an animal to compare their personality to, she’d pick a golden retriever, or perhaps a saint bernard.

Ryder seemed to be on a similar train of thought, gently elbowing the slouching Avery with a gentle sigh. “Hey, don’t say that about yourself. It’s Trevor. He won’t mind a little social awkwardness, and he definitely doesn’t think you’re a doofus.”

Avery lifted their head with the saddest eyes Cecelia had ever seen, as though they were a little kitten being actively rained on in the streets of New York. Before she could really think, she was reaching out and patting their shoulder in a breach of social norms that she only half-realized was occurring. “I don’t think you’re a doofus,” she stated, craning her neck back to make eye contact with them.

Pearly white eyes shifted to look into her chocolate brown ones, and she could see the corners turn up in one of those little smiles people make when they’ve just finished crying and had something like a butterfly land on them. For such a pale tone, they held an unexpected type of depth, warm like toasted marshmallows.

“Thanks kid. It means a lot.”

Cecelia felt her heart glow, flaring slowly in her chest until it-

Stop.

It was like her body had glitched out of reality for a second, brain so shocked by the sudden but subtle change in atmosphere that it forgot it was even a brain. Cecelia’s breath hitched, a shiver running up her spine, goosebumps blooming on her arms. The sun felt colder now, like it was backing away from that fraction of hair-raising terror that was slowly creeping up behind her. Unease, like a restless cat in a carrier, stirred in her gut.

Something’s watching.

“… Hey, you okay? Kid?”

A soft finger reached out to hesitantly tap her forearm, pulling Cecelia back into the real world – to the setting sun and towering trees and cool water – just as she could feel her body coiling to run. Avery was looking at her now, and even with their mask, she could tell their expression was one of gentle concern.

“Are you alright?” they asked again, adjusting their stance so they could look her in the eye. “You seem a little… spooked.”

‘Spooked’ was an understatement and a half, and Cecelia had to stop herself from saying that fact out loud. It would be rude to correct someone who was worried about her, and the truth was there was no word in the English language that could accurately describe the sensation she was beginning to feel.

“I’m okay,” she replied. The lie made her feel a little guilty, so she tacked on “It’s just been a weird day,” to turn it into a half-truth. Between the dream, the morning encounter with Ryder, and the lack of her two new friends at school that day, she felt well within her rights to label it as strange.

“You’re sure? You look really freaked out.”

Cecelia shook her head before Avery could even finish the question, putting her brave face on. “I’m alright, I swear,” she declared as confidently as she could. “I just remembered I have homework to do. Like, right now. I’ve gotta go home and do homework.”

Neither of the spirits could get a word in before Cecelia, fueled by a sudden jolt within her bones, turned and sprinted back up the path she’d come down.

“Good talk!” she called over her shoulder, though she suspected she was already out of earshot. “See you later!”

Ferns brushed past her legs as she continued running. She felt like the protagonist of a horror movie – a sudden sensation that unnerved her deeply. What if something was out there, following her? Were those regular gnarls on that bark, or were those eyes she hadn’t noticed on the way in? The evening was warm in the way that early August evenings often were, but her entire skeleton felt like it was made of ice.

Please be home, Cecelia prayed in her mind as her home came into view. Please be home, please be home…

She needed to get inside. She needed to get inside, and she needed to be with people. She needed safety in numbers, and she needed it now.

The back door swung open, and she darted inside, quick as a shadow. Immediately – and perhaps irrationally – she threw her whole weight against the wood, closing her eyes and not daring to open them until she heard the latch click.

Don’t look outside, don’t look outside…

Almost tripping over herself, Cecelia locked the back door before hurrying into the kitchen. She kept her eyes on the floor and walls, almost certain that if she looked outside, something else would be looking back.

Maybe something with foglight eyes.

“… Cecelia? What are you doing? Dad needs to get in here to make dinner.”

Leroy’s voice hit Cecelia like a splash of cold water, but she relaxed into it like it was the warmest bed in the world. Realizing she was slinking around like a rabid raccoon, she forced herself up from her awkward position, almost hitting her head on the dishwasher handle as she did. “Sorry!” she blurted, brushing off her clothes as if cleaning the imaginary specks of dirt would make this situation less awkward. “Sorry, I just… I thought I saw something. In the woods. A big animal, probably.”

Leroy’s brow furrowed, and he slowly shifted his green eyes from her face to the shaded expanse of their little backyard. Being siblings born only two years apart, Leroy and Cecelia had the mutual power of knowing when the other wasn’t telling the truth.

They also had the power of knowing better than to push it.

“I don’t see anything,” Leroy decided after a moment, voice noticeably softer. “Maybe you just got startled by a deer, or a fox making a really big racket in the ferns.”

His pale, warm hand extended to take hers, gently untangling her fingers from the fabric of her clothing, which she’d been unconsciously clinging to for dear life. Cecelia could feel the shaking of her body, see the tremor in her hands, but Leroy’s grip held her steady.

“Come on,” he urged her patiently, guiding her away from the window and out of the kitchen. “Let’s go see if we can find anything fun to watch on my computer.”

Even if she’d wanted to, Cecelia didn’t protest. The feeling from outside still followed her, but the fear was more of a whisper now, and the sound of Leroy getting out his laptop quietly eased the residual tension.

As the dulcet tones of someone trying and failing to play the kazoo began to fill the room, Cecelia let herself settle in for five minutes of her own nonstop laughter.

She didn’t even notice the way her brother quietly closed the blinds.


Dinner was eaten in Leroy’s room, and the siblings were effectively having their own pseudo-sleepover by the time the clock hit 8pm. That being said, the atmosphere had since deteriorated from cozy and fun to something stiflingly awkward. Cecelia, who normally opened her mouth to talk about a random topic at times like this, found the words glued to the tip of her tongue.

“… So,” Leroy began after what felt like several lifetimes of breathing, “This morning… Uh…”

“It’s real.”

“What?”

“It’s real. That was real.”

Cecelia loved Leroy with all her heart, but him beating around the bush like this made her feel like she was slowly sinking in tar. She knew him, and she knew what the next words out of his mouth would be, and she wanted to just get to the information part already.

“So you’re saying you saw it too?” her brother inquired in a cocktail of tones she was already very used to. Curious, skeptical, cautious, mildly alarmed… the whole nine yards. The kind of tone you’d expect to be followed by a very enthusiastic ‘EUREKA!’ in a variety of films.

“I’m saying I saw it too.”

“You saw the person – er, creature – in the blue hood?”

“Yeah. I saw Ryder.”

“And they were…”

“Not a human in a cosplay.”

Leroy, placing his elbows on his knees and resting his clasped hands against his face, took a deep breath in through his nose.

“So what you’re telling me…”

“Is that cryptids are real and we talked to one this morning.”

“Cecelia, if you were not my sister, I would defenestrate you right now.”

Frustrated, Cecelia threw her hands in the air. “Well what do you want me to say, doofus? ‘Oh yeah, we’re experiencing a collective hallucination!”

“That’s exactly what I want you to say!” the redhead replied, throwing his head back and rubbing his eyes. “Have you ever heard of Occam’s razor? Whatever the simplest answer is, it’s probably the-”

“Us hallucinating is not the simplest explanation!” the younger of the two shot back, frustration growing beneath her ribs. “We have no history of psychosis in our family, and the house is clean and up to date. We’d have to be voluntarily huffing paint fumes to even start seeing things. That was a whole ass person!”

“How is ‘cryptids are real’ logical?!”

“It’s not!”

“Then why are you acting like it is?”

“Because I’ve seen more than just Ryder!”

The blanket she’d had in her lap tumbled to the floor as Cecelia stood up. Her legs began to move all on their own, pacing in anxious steps around the room as she wrung her hands. Leroy was looking at her like she’d just morphed into a very low-budget werewolf, but she didn’t even glance his way.

“There’s Ryder, and then there’s Avery, who I met this Monday. And then there’s this weird lizard lady and a man with a triangle head who I saw in the woods, and they were saying something about giants. This can’t just be explained away, Leroy!”

Her own tone shocked her, and she immediately collapsed to her knees, catching herself on the carpet. Breathe. Breathe. I’m different. Breathe.

One deep breath. Then two. Then three, four, five…

I’m different.

Someone in the room quietly cleared their throat.

“… I’ve… I’ve seen more than just this morning, too.”

The silence broke with Leroy’s soft, almost sheepish admission, which was followed by the sound of him sliding to the floor to join her.

“I met some kids in my class – Iris and Theodore – and they’re not human either. And there’s no way to really deny that, even if I hate to say it. I just… I don’t want to believe that’s what we’re dealing with. We just moved here. Who in their right mind wants to actually acknowledge that their fresh start is in a town that’s probably haunted? Everything’s changing, and now we have to just… upend science and logic?”

Cecelia slowly opened her eyes, looking cautiously up at her brother. His features – very sharp and defined – always seemed to match his understanding of life. Geometric. Straightforward. Always within reason.

But his eyes, like hers, were always soft and full of emotion.

“I’m sorry…”

“Hey, hey, you don’t need to apologize. It’s kind of my fault. I was being stubborn.”

Cecelia shook her head. “I shouldn’t have snapped at you.”

“It’s okay. I know this is… unusual.”

“I sounded like her…”

Leroy pulled his sister close, shushing her softly as she buried her face in his jacket. “You didn’t, Cici. It’s okay. I promise that you didn’t.”

Cecelia wanted to call him a liar, but there were more important topics at hand right now, so she kept her mouth shut. He was just trying to help, after all.

“… What do we do about it?” she murmured against the checkered fabric after a moment, letting Leroy soothingly rub her back. “What happens next?”

Leroy paused, so silent for a moment that Cecelia could practically hear the gears turning in his head. After a moment, he sighed, gently shrugging his shoulders, still careful not to disturb her position. “I don’t know,” he replied softly, tone matter-of-fact. “I guess we just try to rationalize it with what we know, and the more we know, the more we adapt our rationalizations. We know they can talk and go to school, at least, so they must be like people on some level. Whatever else we find out, we just fit into that framework until we get the bigger picture.”

It was such a quintessentially Leroy response to an objectively un-Leroy situation that it almost made Cecelia laugh. This was a situation neither of them fully understood, and Leroy was immediately jumping to organizing it all into little boxes and dissecting the world around them. It was a plan that made sense if you thought about it – observe, inference, adapt – but something about the fact that Leroy was trying to apply scientific thinking to a thing that probably defied all known science was so absurd it was funny. She had to stifle a giggle just so he wouldn’t poke her in the ribs for making fun of him.

“You really think that’s gonna work?” she asked after a moment, the question genuine. Leroy shrugged once more.

“I certainly hope so.”

Hope. 

It had been awhile since she’d heard that word aloud. It felt like evening sunlight spilling warm across her shoulders, like a campfire glowing in the dusk.

“… I do too.”

Comments are closed.